Illegal robocalls and spam texts can be worth $500 to $1,500 each.Free case review

Medicare Robocalls: The Rules Plans and Agents Must Follow

Medicare says it will never call you to sell you anything. Federal rules also prohibit Medicare Advantage and Part D drug plans from cold calling, robocalling, or texting people who have not asked to be contacted. On top of that, a prerecorded or AI-voiced Medicare sales call to your cell phone without your written consent may violate the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), which allows damages of $500 to $1,500 per call.

What Medicare Scam Calls and Robocalls Sound Like

Most unwanted Medicare calls follow one of a few familiar scripts:

  • The benefits pitch. A recording says you may qualify for “extra benefits,” a grocery allowance, or a lower premium, and asks you to press 1 to reach a “licensed agent.”
  • The new card scam. A caller claims you need a new Medicare card and asks you to confirm your Medicare or Social Security number.
  • The fake Medicare office. A live agent says they are “calling from Medicare” or “your benefits office” and wants to review your plan.

The first is usually a sales pitch for Medicare Advantage, Part D, or supplement (Medigap) coverage. The second and third are strong warning signs of fraud. Medicare cards no longer carry Social Security numbers, so anyone asking you to “verify” one for a new card is a red flag.

Does Medicare Call You? What Medicare.gov Says

Medicare’s fraud guidance is clear: “Medicare will never call you to sell you anything or visit you at your home.” Calls asking for personal information should only come in a few narrow situations, such as your own plan or the agent who enrolled you reaching out, or a 1-800-MEDICARE representative returning a message you left.

Medicare also advises against joining a health or drug plan over the phone unless you placed the call yourself. If something feels off, report it to 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227).

Can Medicare Advantage Plans Cold Call You? The CMS Ban Explained

No. Federal marketing rules for Medicare Advantage plans (42 C.F.R. 422.2264), with a matching rule for Part D drug plans, bar unsolicited contact by “telephone solicitation (that is, cold calling), robocalls, text messages, or voicemail,” as well as uninvited door-to-door visits and direct messages on social media.

Plans and their agents may still:

  • contact their own current members about Medicare products;
  • return your calls, or follow up after you send a business reply card; and
  • reach out when you have given permission or started the contact yourself.

If you agree to a sales appointment, that permission generally lasts about a year. These CMS rules are enforced by the government rather than through private lawsuits, and they do not cover Medigap (supplement) sales. Still, an unsolicited Medicare Advantage robocall breaks the plan-side rules, and it may also give you a claim under the TCPA.

How the TCPA Protects You From Medicare Robocalls

For a private claim, the TCPA is the main tool. It applies to Medicare Advantage, Part D, and supplement sellers alike:

  • Recorded or AI voice sales calls to your cell phone need prior express written consent (47 C.F.R. 64.1200(a)(2)). The FCC confirmed in early 2024 that AI-generated voices count as “artificial” voices.
  • Recorded sales calls to your home landline also need written consent (64.1200(a)(3)).
  • Numbers on the Do Not Call Registry are protected, too. Repeated sales calls within a year from or for the same company may be actionable under 47 U.S.C. 227(c)(5).

Damages can be $500 per violation, and up to $1,500 if a court finds the violation willful or knowing. Under newer FCC rules, you can also take back consent in any reasonable way, such as saying “stop” on a call or replying STOP to a text, and the caller must honor it promptly.

The most common defense is “you filled out a form.” Many Medicare leads come from quote or benefit-check websites. If you never visited one, or the form did not clearly authorize that specific company to robocall you, the consent defense may not hold up. See what written consent must include.

Medicare Robocall Lawsuits: Insurers Have Paid to Settle

Large health insurers have faced class action lawsuits over prerecorded calls tied to their Medicare business. In one such case, a major insurer was accused of robocalling the cell phones of people who were not its members and had never agreed to be called.

The insurer chose to settle without admitting wrongdoing, and people who received the calls were able to claim a share of the settlement. Cases like this show that unwanted Medicare robocalls can carry real financial consequences for the companies behind them.

Phone pitches can also misrepresent what a plan covers. Our health insurance robocalls page covers FTC cases against telemarketers that sold limited plans as full coverage.

Not every Medicare call breaks the rules. A call is probably legal when:

  • your current plan calls about your coverage or renewal
  • an agent calls back after you asked for information, within the appointment window, and you have not told them to stop
  • your doctor’s office calls with an appointment reminder; health care messages have their own narrow rules.

How to Protect Yourself From Medicare Phone Scams

A few habits protect your identity and build a record if you decide to take action:

  • Never give your Medicare number to someone who called you. Hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE if you are unsure.
  • Save recorded messages and note the plan or agency the caller named.
  • Ask the agent for their name, their agency, the plan they are selling, and where they got your number.
  • Say “do not call me again” and write down the date.
  • Keep a call log. Our evidence log helps you count calls per company.

Report suspected fraud to Medicare first. Then, if a named agency or plan keeps robocalling you, gather your recordings and dates and ask for a free case review. A lawyer can check whether the calls broke the TCPA’s consent rules and whether the plan that benefited is responsible for its marketer.

If calls arrived very early in the morning or late at night, note that too. Federal law limits calling hours, and some states set tighter windows. Our calling hours rules explain why it matters. Legal claims also have time limits, so it is wise to act sooner rather than later.

Medicare Robocall FAQs

Does Medicare call you on the phone?

Medicare says it will never call you to sell you anything. It contacts you by phone only in limited situations, such as returning a message you left.

Can Medicare Advantage plans cold call me?

No. Under 42 C.F.R. 422.2264, plans may not make unsolicited contact by cold calls, robocalls, texts, or voicemail. They can call current members, return your call, or call when you have given permission.

Can I sue over Medicare robocalls?

You may have a claim if the calls used a recorded or AI voice without your written consent, or broke Do Not Call rules, and you can identify the company behind them. The TCPA allows $500 to $1,500 per call.

How do I stop Medicare robocalls?

Register your number at donotcall.gov, tell each caller not to call again, and report suspected fraud to 1-800-MEDICARE. Keep a log in case the calls continue.

Sources

  1. Medicare.gov: Reporting Medicare fraud and abuse
  2. 42 C.F.R. 422.2264, beneficiary contact (Cornell LII)
  3. ClassAction.org: $2.5M UnitedHealthcare TCPA settlement (Samson v. UnitedHealthcare)
  4. FCC 24-17, Declaratory Ruling on AI-generated voices
  5. 47 C.F.R. 64.1200 (Cornell LII)

Free case review

Getting calls or texts you never agreed to?

Tell us who is calling and how often. Every submission is reviewed. If you can't name the company yet, the form will show you how to find out.

  • No fee unless you recover
  • Nationwide, through co-counsel where needed
  • Takes about 2 minutes

Do You Qualify?

Illegal calls and texts can be worth $500 to $1,500 each. Three quick steps, about a minute.

Step 1 of 3: What is happening

What are you getting? Choose all that apply
Which phone do they reach? Choose all that apply
Do you know the name of the company?

See if you qualify: free case review